The four real options
| Option | Typical price | Who configures it and gives support |
|---|---|---|
| Google Workspace | ~$120 MXN | You. Support by ticket, almost always in English. |
| Microsoft 365 | ~$120 MXN | You. Same, with more options and more complexity. |
| Shared hosting with email | hundreds of pesos for the WHOLE plan |
Nobody. The accounts come as one more checkbox on the spec sheet. |
| Local agency or consultant | $150–250 MXN | Them, in theory. In practice it depends on how busy they are. |
| Platform + administration | list-price licence + monthly retainer |
A specialised third party, with the account in the client's name. |
About these figures. Google's and Microsoft's prices are approximate, they change with the exchange rate and with whatever promotion is running, and they vary by plan. They are here to give an order of magnitude — check the current one on their site before deciding. The agency figures come from what we have seen charged in the Mexican market.
The hosting plan that comes with "50 email accounts"
It is the comparison almost every prospect makes, and it deserves to be made properly. Shared hosting providers in Mexico sell plans where email accounts are a checkbox on the spec sheet, next to disk space and bandwidth. Fifty accounts is usually the entry plan, and it costs a few hundred pesos a month for everything.
Compared with that, any managed email looks wildly expensive. So it is worth stating clearly what you are comparing:
| Hosting with email included | Managed email | |
|---|---|---|
| The IP you send from | shared with the server's other customers | managed reputation |
| SPF, DKIM, DMARC | you, with their documentation | configured and monitored |
| If a neighbour sends spam | your email goes to the blacklist with their IP | not applicable |
| Migration | yours | included |
| When something fails | ticket | WhatsApp with a person |
| Uptime guarantee | none enforceable | 99.9% or that month is on us |
If your email is internal exchange and the odd attachment, shared hosting is enough for you and there is no point paying more. If email is how you quote, invoice and get paid, what you are buying is not the fifty checkboxes: it is that they arrive.
It is also worth looking at the promises. It is common to see "99.999% uptime" on shared hosting plans. Five nines is five minutes of downtime a year, something only dedicated infrastructure with real redundancy sustains. The useful question in any case — ours included — is "and what happens if they don't meet it?". If the answer doesn't come with a consequence, the number is decorative.
What doesn't appear on the price tag
This is where the comparison is decided, and almost nobody makes it.
The migration
Moving the email of a twenty-person company is half a day's work if you know how, and a week of incidents if you don't. Google and Microsoft don't do it: they give you documentation. Agencies usually charge for it separately, between three and fifteen thousand pesos.
The deliverability setup
SPF, DKIM and DMARC don't come solved by signing up for a platform. Google gives you the instructions; getting them right — especially with several services sending through your domain — is technical work. If it is left half done, your email starts landing in spam and nobody knows why. It is the most common cause.
Your people's time
It is the biggest cost and the one never counted. If someone on your team spends four hours a month keeping email working, that time costs more than the difference between every option in the table.
The email that never arrived
A quote that landed in spam and went unanswered. It appears on no invoice and is usually the most expensive item on the list, even though it can never be measured precisely.
The decision you are actually making
Notice something: between Google, Microsoft and decent hosting, the licence difference is a few hundred pesos a month for a mid-sized company. That is not what gets decided. What gets decided is who takes charge, and there the options are three:
| Who administers it | What it costs | What happens when something fails |
|---|---|---|
| Nobody — you sign up and that's it | just the licence | Nothing, until one day the email goes to spam and nobody knows why. |
| Someone on your team | licence + their time | They deal with it when they can, between their other responsibilities. |
| A specialised third party | licence + retainer | It is their job, with a committed response time. |
The first row is free and is the most expensive of the three, because the cost shows up as quotes that went unanswered. It simply doesn't arrive on an invoice, so nobody adds it up.
Why the licence goes separately and in your name
There are two ways for someone to administer your email. One is to resell you the licence at a mark-up; the other is for you to buy it directly and pay them separately for administering it.
The second is better for you for three reasons: you see exactly what you pay to whom, whoever administers it doesn't earn more by selling you extra licences, and the account is yours — if one day you change adviser you lose nothing and don't have to migrate again. It is how an external CIO works, and the way we do it.
When you should NOT hire us
Three cases, in all honesty:
- If you are two or three people and don't use shared documents. Google Workspace on its entry plan works out well for you, it is simple to administer, and the saving of having someone else run it doesn't pay off at that size.
- If your email is already well configured and gives you no trouble. Run the free check. If it comes back clean and your team knows how to keep it that way, you don't need a monthly retainer — you need someone to review it once a year, and that is a different conversation.
- If you have in-house IT staff with time to spare. Everything we do can be done in-house. Our value is that you don't have to assign anyone to it.
It suits us to say this, because the client who leaves after three months costs more than they brought in.
When it does make sense
- Five mailboxes or more, with no in-house IT staff.
- Email that is already landing in spam and nobody knows why.
- An agency charging $150 or more that takes days to reply.
- Email is where the sale or the invoicing happens, and it cannot fail.
Before comparing prices, look at where you stand
If your current setup has gaps, switching without seeing them drags them to the new provider. The check is free and takes seconds.
The question that does settle the decision
It isn't "which platform is cheaper". Google and Microsoft are both good and cost almost the same. It is "who fixes it on the Tuesday an invoice doesn't arrive?". If the answer is someone on your team, you are paying that salary on top of the licence. If it is a ticket in English, you are paying for the wait. That — and not the gigabytes in the mailbox — is what you are buying.
Keep reading
- Switching provider without losing a message What actually happens in a migration and what to demand from whoever does it.
- My emails land in spam: 7 causes The cost that appears on no invoice.